LG’s S-CLASS User Interface: What do you think about it?

I recently criticized the apparently award winning LG S-Class user interface for being too inconsistent, having too many screens, flows, icons, mess.

Well, I was wrong!

Or right?

Or both???

Check for yourself – there’s a complete emulator of the S-Class UI in LG’s website and you can see it all in action: link to emulator.

When you finish playing with the emulator, come back, leave your comment or vote in this poll: Is it good? bad? both? Will it serve well for LG’s windows mobile phones?

I think it’s much better than previously seen in the videos. I think that the videos gave a very bad impression, but playing with the shell seems to be nice and smooth.

Of course, the emulator can deceive a little bit as this is not running on Windows Mobile, and I still think that some of the screens are just too messy and could have been more simple, (and I still don’t like the copied iPhone icons in the widgets section), but overall, I have better opinion now than I originally had.