iPhone Windows Phone Xbox - 25 January 2012
Author: Doug Smith

Tim-Cook-Apple-CEO-1So I’m finishing up writing rumors and speculation on Apple putting a 4 inch screen in the next iPhone which may or may not be called the iPhone 5, but who really cares right? The fact of the matter is that Apple devices are highly regarded by the public and they sell a massive amount of them. Fresh out of thinking about Apple and I check out Paul Thurrott’ s site, which is totally geared towards the Microsoft experience, PC, Phone, and Web.

Paul says that during the Apple quarterly earnings conference call yesterday, the one where Apple sold more devices than anyone else and made more profit than anyone else in history except Exxon in 2008. Wow. But during the question and answer session Tim Cook, Apple CEO, was “asked about Android and whether the smartphone market was a “two-horse race””. This all happening at “the 57:18 mark of the conference call that you can listen over at the Apple Investor Relations page. Here is what Tim has to say:

“I wouldn’t say it’s a two-horse race. There’s a horse in Redmond that always suits up and always runs, and will keep running. And there’s other players that we can never count out. And so what we focus on is innovating and making the world’s best products. And we’ll just keep on doing that and in some part just ignore how many horses there are. And we just want stay ahead and be the lead one.”

Paul goes on to explain the Windows Phone market share currently at 1.5% and that mentioning Windows Phone when your company just sold 37 million devices is either Respect or Subterfuge. Paul actually titles his post “Tim Cook’s Windows Phone Mention: Respect Or Subterfuge?” Paul ends his article with a question: “So. why did Tim Cook even mention that Microsoft was a competitor in this market?”

Well, maybe I can shed some light on it from a current iPhone daily driver’s point of view who just starting off using a Windows Phone. I really like my iPhone 4S. It never bogs down, it never fails, I don’t have the dropped calls issue, and the apps. The iPhone has tons of them. But when I first got the Titan, the speed was actually faster than the iPhone. It is amazingly fast and smooth. Opening and closing apps, making calls, it just works. Reading email on a Windows Phone is so much better than the iPhone and Android. Windows Phone keeps you connected with a people hub that is just fantastic. I get a complete story on the person I want to follow which includes phone calls, texts, Facebook, and Twitter entries from them all listed in order. No more app jumping. Live tiles is so refreshing as well. I really like weather, news, people, and email updates on the today screen. You can pin most anything there. At first, I was not a fan of Metro, Microsoft’s now  universal approach to viewing your PC, XBOX, and Phone. (PC is coming in Win 8). Metro is clean, almost surgical precision and not just a cluttered up mess that is hard to read.

Windows Phone can also bet on quality device manufacturer support from the likes of red hot Samsung, HTC, and now Nokia. You get a solid hardware experience. No, it is not a dual core processor. It’s a single core 1.5GHz that powers my Titan and if never told me it was a Single core and that it was a Dual Core, the same as in every Android device, I would believe you. The Camera on the Titan is excellent. I would say almost as good as the iPhone 4S, but better than anything I have used on an Android device. It is not just with these high end devices that Microsoft hopes to cash in. With the release of Tango, the next Windows Phone operating system after Mango (I didn’t make that up, that’s what they called them!), Windows Phone will be able to perform on lower end hardware specs, something Android could never hope to do. What this will do is give Microsoft a product they can put a 1GHz processor in and market off contract for $200.00. You can’t touch a decent smartphone these days off contract for less than $500.00. We have already seen Apple offer different price points for their phones, like the 3GS for free with 2 year contract and the iPhone 4 for $99. Can you imagine a $200.00 off contract smartphone that actually will perform well?

So why did Tim say that you can’t count out Windows Phone and Microsoft? I think it is because that he has most likely picked up a Windows Phone and thought the same thing as I did. This thing is for real. But is a solid device, with a  fresh new operating system enough? Microsoft knew better. They started out with a full on assault to get developers excited and developing for Windows Phone.  And it appears that Microsoft is also going to be willing to put it’s money where it’s apps are. Specifically, they will be investing 10’s of millions of dollars over the next three years. Microsoft has also said it will release the top 25 apps from both iPhone and Android by the end of the first half of 2012. Could this finally mean Zynga games?  Then, there is the XBOX integration into Windows Phone.  XBOX, who as everyone knows, enjoys tremendous success, has also adopted the Metro UI similar to that of the Windows Phone. So what’s left? How about Windows 8? Microsoft, after a very successful Windows 7 release, is set to follow up with Windows 8 which will be yet another Metro inspired experience that will take PC users in a whole new direction and user experience. So what we have is three stars converging to a single point all integrating a single user experience. Sounds impressive right? Yeah, I thought so too. More so, I think Tim Cook thinks so.

1.5% market share is not a lot to get up and sing about. However, analysts are saying that by the end of 2012 Microsoft potentially could exit with a 10% market share. But then Microsoft has the time, money, and experience to know this is not an over night race.  My guess is that Microsoft knew that the three stars I mentioned above would converge to a single point and that’s when they will really start caring and marketing their product. I think that’s why Tim Cook said “that Horse always suits up and always runs”. Tim has certainly got his hands full trying to fill the shoes of his predecessor Steve Jobs, but making comments like that makes me think he’s got a lot on the ball, and knows that he has to stay vigilant against Titans that many think are only resting.









About Author

Doug Smith

Mobility junkie who loves to share information and talk tech. Never uses the same device for long and is currently using a Motorola Droid RAZR, HTC Titan, and iPhone 4S.

(7) Readers Comments

  1. I know you weren’t into WP7 so it’s great to see you coming around to it. I think you’re right. Apple knows that WP will be gaining tractions over the next year. They’re stating what everyone else believes as well. Even if MS gets an increased share, the number of smartphone users is growing even faster so they’ll still have more sales year after year and they don’t need to dominate the market to have crazy sales figures and even crazier profits.

  2. Great article. A couple of thoughts after reading it.

    Tim Cook strikes me as a very intelligent man, he’s also very good businessman. He’s been credited with developing the supply chain that Apple is now renowned for and that means the guy knows how to produce results. I think the common misconception is that competitors haven’t picked up each other’s devices and explored the UI. Its just good business to do so.

    Microsoft not only has long money but also are clearly learning from Apple. Microsoft has openly stated how they are taking cues from Apple’s consumer success and realize that their own products have to be more intuitive and be more devices than computers. This means that the mandate from one of Apple’s chief competitors is to watch, learn and be inspired to create products that are both beautiful and intuitive. Thats worth keeping an eye on.

    Finally Xbox Live titles will be coming to iOS and Android. That means, Smith, that instead of Zynga being the thing that makes you feel so alone when using the Windows Phone all your iOS friends will probably start playing Xbox Live titles and you can get your game on. That means that in a roundabout way Microsoft is creating a cross platform solution inside Apple’s walled garden.

    Finally, despite all the grandstanding Apple knows Microsoft is determined to prove everyone who doubts them wrong. Never repeat the mistake of dismissing a competitor the way Ballmer did years ago about Apple and the iPhone. Yes Cook is not just an intelligent man, he is historically aware.

  3. Ahh, a refreshing view from an iOwner.

  4. You better be scared apple troll. Windows phone is back and twice better. Just look at how fast and fluid the smartphone runs and look at the UI look so awesome. IPhone boring dead candy icons zzzzzzz boring and surely dead.

  5. This was a refreshing peace of reading. Almost every tech writer out there is somewhat close-minded.

    Even though I am a WP fanboi, i felt that maybe you should’ve mentioned some of the shortcomings of WP, to make it even more balanced. Still, great piece.

  6. Microsoft has made many mistakes in the past, but starting with Xbox360, Windows 7, Windows Phone and continuing into Windows 8, all these products are very well done. For years I’ve been wondering about a user interface that would work on any screen size, with mouse, touch, movement, etc. and it was always almost impossible to imagine until I saw and used MetroUI in Windows Phone, Xbox/Kinect and Windows 8. This is the boldest move Microsoft has ever done, and it will pay off.

    As developers find a common UI and developing tools that allows them to place their apps in all these form factors with little or no modification, as users start getting used to Metro, the traction that Microsoft can gain is greater than the sum of individual parts.

    I just can’t go back to grids of static icons, they seem to me the dumbest UI elements ever done and every time I see someone with an iPhone or Android trying to find an app in pages of grids of icons it tickles my nerves the utter inefficiency and wasting of time.

    Windows 8 is still not completely understood, but the research on human behavior behind it is solid. Instead of a start button with more icons and apps, the start is a metroUI panel with live tiles, just like WP. It will work in the desktop as well, because when someone sits at a computer the first thing they do is start opening different apps to get a picture of the news, events, emails and social updates. The Windows 8 start screen will give you all that in a second, and give you access to apps as well, exposing instead of hiding. I look forward to see how it evolves.

  7. Smith I am impressed. You’re beginning to get the hang of this (PostRank agrees bigtime).

    Don’t forget to engage the readers with responses to comments on your articles, especially when you manage to crank out a winner. Gotta get the site a reputation within its audience of having writers that do that. It’s good for business, makes the readers feel starstruck.

    I’d tell you guys that your platform is continuing to climb this year but Microsoft Facebook just pulled the plug on publishing application usage figures on everything except WP. That sucks. But if I had to guess I’d say you’ve gained some traction this month finally. A lil’ bit.